The Science Is Screaming: Don’t Make This Trendy Mistake

This article was previously published November 11, 2011, and has been updated with new information.

The science is loud and clear: The correct balance of fatty acids is essential if you want to be the healthiest you can be. That means that maintaining a healthy ratio of omega-6 to omega-3 is important for optimal health. Ideally, you want to maintain a 4-to-1 ratio, or less.

However, studies show that most people are consuming as much as a 12-to-1 ratio, which can be attributed to the consumption of too much α-linolenic acid (ALA), the primary sources of which are vegetable oils such as soybean and canola.¹

It’s unfortunate that most people have been fooled by a decades-long fad promoting vegetable oils as the key to good eating and a long life when, in fact, it is a road to ill health and chronic disease. History shows that our lopsided consumption of ALAs began in the early 1900s, when people were discouraged from eating natural animal fats such as butter and lard.²

We now know that refined vegetable oils are among the worst foods to consume, and that we need to limit ALA consumption. As a group, when consumed in the wrong ratios, these fats tend to stimulate inflammatory processes in your body, rather than inhibit them. There are actually two problems related to how fats are being consumed in the U.S. today:

1. Most people are consuming far too many omega-6 fats compared to omega-3 fats. As mentioned, the ideal ratio of omega-6 to omega-3 fats is 4-to-1, but this is nearly impossible to achieve if you’re regularly eating processed foods or restaurant fare, as these are loaded with omega-6 from industrial vegetable oils.
2. Americans are also consuming far too many polyunsaturated fats (PUFAs). While both omega-3 and omega-6 fats are PUFAs and essential to your health, when omega-6 is consumed in excess, it becomes problematic. In fact, too many PUFAs contribute to chronic inflammation over the long term.

It is easy to get confused when reading about the different types of fats — there are saturated fats and unsaturated fats, omega-3s and omega-6s, PUFAs, long-chain and short-chain fats, and the list goes on.

In order to help clear up the confusion, this article aims to provide you with a “primer” on fatty acids to increase your understanding of the fundamental differences between the types of fats and how your body uses them. So let’s start by taking a look at the overall category called “fats”—what they’re made of and what they do for you. And then we’ll take a closer look at PUFAs and omega-3s.

Fats for Dummies

Fats are one member of a group of water-insoluble substances called “lipids.” Lipids³ are important to you because they are the primary components of your cell membranes. Other members of the lipid group include sterols, phospholipids, triglycerides and waxes.

Fats both in foods and in your body are simply storage units composed of fatty acids. A fat is distinguished by the specific combination of fatty acids making it up. Fatty acids have three basic purposes in your body:⁴

1. Providing energy
2. Providing the building blocks for cell membranes and metabolism
3. Acting as raw materials that can be converted to other substances that perform special duties in your body such as hormones

The properties of fats and fatty acids depend on their degree of hydrogen saturation and the length of their molecules, or “chain length.” Chemically, a fatty acid is a chain of carbon atoms with pairs of hydrogen atoms attached, with an “acid group” attached to one end of the molecule.

There are four basic types of fatty acids, based on how many of their carbon bonds are paired with hydrogen:⁵

Vegetable oils and animal fats are typically composed of a mixture of these different fatty acid types. For example, olive oil is mostly monounsaturated fat with a small amount of polyunsaturated fat.⁶ Lard is primarily 39.2% saturated fat and 45.1% monounsaturated fat, but contains some polyunsaturated fat as well.⁷

Most vegetable oils are high in PUFAs, whereas most animal fats are high in saturated and monounsaturated fats (except for palm, coconut and olive oils). Saturated and monounsaturated fats are more easily used by your body than polyunsaturated fats.

Fats vary in the length of their carbon chains, leading to another classification scheme based on their number of carbon atoms:⁸

• Short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs) — Two to four carbon atoms
• Medium-chain fatty acids (MCFAs) — Six to 10 carbon atoms
• Long-chain fatty acids (LCFAs) — Twelve to 26 carbon atoms
• Very-long-chain fatty acids⁹ (VLCFAs) — Twenty-six to 30 carbon atoms

A fatty acid’s chain length and saturation control its melting point. As chain length increases, melting point increases. Likewise, fats that are solid at room temperature (butter, coconut oil) have longer chain lengths than fats that are liquid at room temperature (fish oil, olive oil). With chain lengths being equal, unsaturated fats have lower melting points than saturated fats.

The Chemical Instability of Polyunsaturated Fats (PUFAs)

Because your tissues are made up mostly of saturated and monounsaturated fats, your body requires more of them than polyunsaturated fats (which is true of all mammals). The main dietary PUFAs are omega-3 and omega-6 fats. Although your body does need these, it needs them in relatively small quantities.

One of the problems with PUFAs is that they are very chemically unstable, and highly susceptible to being altered and denatured by what’s around them. Think about what happens to the oils in your pantry — they are susceptible to going rancid as a result of oxidation. In your body, PUFAs undergo a similar process when exposed to the toxic byproducts of proteins and sugars — especially fructose.

This is why most fish oil supplements have such a short shelf life, and many are already oxidized before they hit the bottle. Consuming oxidized fats can do your body more harm than good.

When you eat too many PUFAs, they are increasingly incorporated into your cell membranes. Because these fats are unstable, your cells become fragile and prone to oxidation, which leads to all sorts of health problems, such as atherosclerosis. Now let’s take a look at the most common PUFAs in your diet—the omega fats.

The Omega Fats

The end of the fatty acid chain, opposite the acid end, is the “omega end.” The location of the first double bond from the omega end dictates whether a fatty acid is an omega-3, omega-6, omega-9 (oleic acid), or another member of the “omega family.” Both omega-3s and omega-6s come in both short-and long-chain varieties.

Fats: Understanding the Essentials

“Essential fatty acids” (EFAs) is a term referring to the PUFAs your body needs but cannot produce (or convert from other fats), so they must be obtained from your diet.

Traditionally, only two fats were considered “essential” — ALA (an omega-3 fat) and LA (an omega-6 fat). However, we now know it’s the long-chain derivatives — arachidonic acid, DHA, and EPA — that your body needs the most. Although you have the enzymes to convert LA into these longer-chain fats (ALA, DHA and EPA), the conversion isn’t efficient enough for optimal brain growth and development.

This has led to a recent rethinking of what fats to consider “essential” and recommendations for adding more long-chain fats to your diet, to better meet these biological demands.

DHA and EPA: The ‘Anti-Inflammatory Fats’

Scientific studies have uncovered a number of important health benefits from omega-3 fats, and it’s looking more like it’s DHA and EPA that are responsible for those benefits, rather than ALA. Science suggests that omega-3s offer the following benefits to your health:¹⁴

One reason omega-3s are so good for you is their anti-inflammatory properties, especially the omega-3s from animal sources. In the case of DHA, your tissues use this fatty acid it to synthesize compounds called “resolvins,” which help to reduce inflammation. According to the Weston A. Price Foundation:¹⁵

“Sufficient DHA allows the immune system to mount a robust inflammatory response against invading pathogens or damaged tissues and to bring the response quickly to an end once the task has been accomplished.

Researchers are increasingly discovering that most degenerative diseases involve an element of chronic, low-level inflammation, and the inability to “turn off” important inflammatory processes once they are no longer needed could be part of the problem. DHA deficiency may therefore be at the root of widespread declines in cognitive function, increases in mental disorders and epidemic levels of degenerative disease.”

A study in the journal Pediatrics¹⁶ even showed that supplementing a mother’s DHA during pregnancy and lactation improves her child’s IQ at 4 years of age. EPA, which accumulates in fish, is a precursor to DHA.

Just like DHA, EPA also helps to control inflammation, but this time by interfering with arachidonic acid metabolism. Arachidonic acid is the precursor to PGE2 (a prostaglandin), which is a major initiator of inflammation. You can see how DHA and EPA would work together to naturally reduce inflammation and improve inflammatory conditions like rheumatoid arthritis and asthma.

In rheumatoid arthritis, EPA/DHA supplementation has been shown to reduce joint stiffness and soreness and improve flexibility. And for asthma, a study¹⁷ involving fish oil supplementation for asthmatic children (along with improved diet) resulted in better airway function and reduced need for asthma medications, without side effects.

The most profound benefits of EPA may lie in its implications for people at high risk for coronary artery disease. But science has shown that EPA/DHA supplementation can benefit people with other conditions as well, such as:

• EPA/DHA supplementation has helped people with ulcerative colitis.¹⁸
• Several studies have shown that people with schizophrenia often have low levels of the particular EFAs necessary for normal nerve cell membrane metabolism. Early results from a few trials suggest EPA can have a positive effect on the mental status of schizophrenics.¹⁹
• Epidemiological evidence suggests that populations consuming marine diets rich in EPA have a low incidence of cancer.²⁰ Experimental studies, both in vitro and in vivo, further support EPA’s anticancer activity.

EPA and Your Heart

Even though the medical establishment for decades has advised you to consume vegetable oils (omega-6 PUFAs) to prevent heart disease, human trials have conclusively demonstrated that vegetable oils do not decrease atherosclerosis or decrease your risk of dying from cardiovascular disease.

There is a widespread medical myth that atherosclerotic plaque is caused by too much LDL and cholesterol in your blood. Yet, this is not what the research shows! Instead, science tells us that the mechanism driving atherosclerosis is actually the oxidation of PUFAs in your LDL membrane. You may recall that excess PUFAs lead to fragile cell membranes that can easily be damaged by oxidation.

Furthermore, high LDL appears to be a sign of cholesterol sulfate deficiency — it’s your body’s way of trying to maintain the correct balance by taking damaged LDL and turning it into plaque, within which the blood platelets produce the cholesterol sulfate your heart and brain needs for optimal function.

What this also means is that when you artificially lower your cholesterol with a statin drug, which effectively reduces that plaque but doesn’t address the root problem, your body is not able to compensate any longer, and as a result of lack of cholesterol sulfate you may end up with heart failure. So that I can be perfectly clear about this, I’ll repeat it again:

Atherosclerosis is NOT caused by the amount of cholesterol carried by your LDL, but by oxidative damage to weak cell membranes, resulting from a diet too high in PUFAs and too low in saturated fats.

It is no wonder, then, that trials attempting to prevent heart disease with diets rich in polyunsaturated vegetable oils have failed so miserably! Even the US FDA, which denies most nutritional claims, acknowledges the following cardiovascular benefits of dietary animal-based omega-3 fats.

And the opposite can be said of diets rich in EPA, which have been scientifically shown to improve heart health by:^21,22

• Lowering lipid and triglyceride levels in your blood
• Decreasing blood viscosity
• Reducing platelet aggregation, thereby reducing the likelihood of a clot
• Reducing your chances of heart attack

Marine oils are an excellent source of EPA-and DHA-rich omega-3 fats. Many cultures around the world that subsist on traditional diets have very low to nonexistent cardiovascular disease. Many of these cultures have a high intake of marine oils (e.g., the Inuit) — but some do not. However, what ALL of these groups do have in common is the near absence of refined foods.

If you are eating standard American fare, simply taking an omega-3 supplement may not be enough because it needs to be implemented as part of a total nutrition plan which should include eliminating refined/processed food and excess sugar and grains, and a return to whole foods, with an emphasis on fresh organic vegetables and meats. Basically, it’s a return to what our ancestors ate. So, how do you know if you’re getting enough omega-3 fats?

Signs and Symptoms of Fatty Acid Deficiency

To get your omega-3 to omega-6 ratio closer to ideal, simply cut back on all vegetable oils (this includes processed foods, which are loaded with vegetable oils), and begin consuming sources of high-quality omega-3 fats daily. My favorite omega-3 supplement is krill oil, which I’ll discuss in a moment. Common signs and symptoms that your omega-3 to omega-6 ratio may be out of balance include:²³

Certain clusters of symptoms may indicate other fatty acid deficiencies. For example, if you have a deficiency in arachidonic acid, the following symptoms are typical:

• Dry, itchy, scaly skin
• Dandruff and/or hair loss
• Reproductive difficulties
• Gastrointestinal disturbances
• Food intolerances

Deficiencies in either arachidonic acid or DHA²⁴ can result in poor growth, poor immune function and inflammation. DHA deficiency has been linked to ADHD, depression and Alzheimer’s disease, which is understandable as DHA is so critical to your neurological function. If your deficiency is in DHA, you are more likely to experience these symptoms:

• Numbness or tingling
• Weakness or pain
• Psychological disturbances
• Poor cognition
• Poor visual acuity

Plant-Based Versus Animal-based Omega-3 Fats

There are many who argue you can get all of the omega-3 fats you need from plant sources, but I disagree. Plant-based omega-3 sources include flax, hemp, and chia seeds, which are all high in ALA. Your body can convert ALA into EPA and DHA — but only in small quantities, as I discussed earlier. While you certainly should consume these plant-based fats, you cannot rely on them exclusively to meet all your body’s omega-3 fat requirements.

Your body needs all three omega-3 fats (ALA, EPA and DHA), and for this, you need both plant AND animal sources. You should avoid taking DHA-only products, for the same reason.

For optimal health, then, it boils down to the need for balance among these various essential fats, and you can achieve this balance by eating a diet that incorporates a wide variety of whole foods from both plant and animal sources, and a good omega-3 supplement.

My No. 1 Choice for Omega-3 Supplementation

In a perfect world, you’d get all of the animal-based omega-3s you needed from eating fish and seafood. But the sad reality is that industrial pollution has contaminated most of the world’s fish and seafood with a variety of dangerous toxins like mercury and PCBs. The one exception is krill oil, my favorite omega-3 fat supplement. Krill does not generally have this contamination. I believe it’s the best omega-3 source for the following four reasons:

Articles